At first glance, in fact, the New York Knicks’ best play looks like a failure.
As the New York Knicks fight their way through the NBA playoffs, a rather unusual strategy underpins their success: the vigorous pursuit of rebounding their own missed shots. This tactical embrace of imperfection provides a fitting metaphor for contemporary business practices in an age marked by rapid technological advances and unpredictable market dynamics. Much like the Knicks, modern enterprises are increasingly recognizing the power of leveraging their mistakes and setbacks as catalysts for innovation and growth.
In the Knicks’ case it means: They ranked as an average 3-point shooting team this season, and a below-average shooting team overall. That they have figured out a way to turn those misfires into an advantage, hustling their way to 14.5 offensive rebounds per game — the most in the entire NBA, according to Stats Perform — has delighted a fan base with a deep love for blue-collar basketball.
“It’s a hustle stat that shows effort, just getting after it and not quitting,” said Casey Powell, a popular Knicks podcaster (CP “The Fanchise”). And last night against the Pacers they did it again: Knicks vs. Pacers: 121–117.
Learning from the Knicks’ Playbook
The Knicks have made a virtue out of a necessity. Despite being average at shooting, they lead the NBA in offensive rebounds this postseason, which has transformed potential failures — missed shots — into second chances and scoring opportunities. This approach not only compensates for their shooting deficiencies but also epitomizes a resilience that is highly valued in New York’s sports culture. The team’s strategy, driven by players like Josh Hart and guided by coach Tom Thibodeau’s philosophy, underscores a larger truth: relentless effort can turn apparent disadvantages into winning assets.
Throughout this season, and over the course of their first-round playoff win against the Philadelphia 76ers, the Knicks have missed plenty of scoring chances. Luckily for them, that’s just when the fun begins — because no team in basketball is more adept at grabbing those misses and converting them into points. So, the Knicks have scored 19.2 “second-chance” points per game — the most of any team this postseason.
Harnessing Self-Awareness for Competitive Advantage
In both basketball and business, a deep understanding of one’s strengths and weaknesses not only informs strategic decisions but also shapes a sustainable path to success. This self-awareness acts as a foundational principle that enables teams and companies alike to construct strategies that amplify their strengths and mitigate their weaknesses.
In the context of basketball, the New York Knicks have excelled by capitalizing on their robust rebounding capabilities, an acknowledgment of their less-than-stellar shooting accuracy. By focusing on what they do best — hustling for offensive rebounds — they’ve crafted a competitive edge that is uniquely suited to their team’s makeup. This strategic self-awareness allows them to compete effectively against teams that might surpass them in shooting proficiency but fall short in tenacity on the boards.
Similarly, in the business realm, organizations gain a competitive advantage by critically assessing their core competencies and limitations. This approach of building on an honest evaluation of strengths and weaknesses ensures that resources are allocated efficiently, and efforts are directed toward areas with the highest return on investment. Moreover, it prepares organizations to face competitive pressures with resilience, adapting their strategies dynamically to meet the shifting landscapes of market and competition.
Corporate Strategies: The Imperfectionists at Work
Parallel to the Knicks’ rebound strategy, the corporate world is also learning to navigate the unpredictable currents of the global economy by adopting what Robert McLean and Charles Conn describe as a strategy of “smaller yet bold steps” in their book, The Imperfectionists: Strategic Mindsets for Uncertain Times. They argue that in a volatile business environment, the quest for perfection and certainty often leads to missed opportunities. Instead, embracing imperfection and learning from mistakes can lead to more innovative and adaptable business practices.
This philosophy aligns with the concept of ‘small bets’ — a strategy proposed by innovation experts that suggests organizations can drive significant innovations through small, experimental investments. These small bets allow companies to test ideas without committing extensive resources, learn from their failures, and refine their strategies more effectively. By focusing on agility rather than accuracy, businesses can navigate uncertainties more flexibly and creatively.
Examples of Embracing Failures
- Tech Startups: In the tech industry, rapid prototyping and iterative development are commonplace. Companies like Spotify and Netflix continually roll out new features in limited releases, learn from user feedback, and adjust before full deployment. This approach not only mitigates risk but also turns potential failures into lessons that fuel innovation.
- Pharmaceuticals: The development of the COVID-19 vaccines showcased the value of iterative trials and rapid adaptation in response to new scientific insights and regulatory feedback. The unprecedented speed of vaccine development was partly due to embracing the iterative learning from clinical trials.
- Automotive Industry: Tesla’s approach to software updates allows the company to refine its vehicle software continuously based on real-world data and user feedback, often fixing issues that could have been seen as failures or oversights.
Implications for Business Leaders
For business leaders, the takeaway from the Knicks’ strategy and the broader business landscape is clear: do not shy away from taking risks or fear the stigma of failure. Instead, create a culture that encourages innovation through experimentation. Leaders should emphasize learning and quick recovery from setbacks, much like a basketball team (or Carlos Sainz) hustling for every offensive rebound.
Yes, created by AI, of course.
The strategic embrace of imperfections and the emphasis on leveraging one’s strengths, as exemplified by the Knicks, offer rich insights for everyone navigating today’s complex and fast-paced market environments. Executives can implement these lessons in their everyday life and translate them into effective business strategies in the following ways:
- Cultivating a Resilient Mindset: The first lesson is about fostering a culture that doesn’t just tolerate failure but actively learns from it. This involves creating an environment where employees are encouraged to take calculated risks. When failures occur, the focus should be on extracting valuable lessons and quickly pivoting strategies based on those insights. This mindset mirrors the Knicks’ approach to rebounding where missed shots are not seen as failures but as opportunities to score.
- Strategic Resource Allocation: Understanding the team’s unique strengths and weaknesses allows leaders to allocate resources more effectively. For instance, investing in areas that leverage an organization’s core competencies can yield more substantial returns than trying to improve areas of chronic weakness. This is akin to the Knicks focusing on enhancing their rebounding skills rather than focussing too much on their shooting deficits, which may offer less immediate benefits.
- Dynamic Strategy Adjustment: Business leaders can take a page from the sports strategy playbook by maintaining flexibility in their strategic planning. Just as a basketball coach adjusts tactics based on the team’s strengths, the game’s progress, and the opponent’s strategy, business leaders must be prepared to pivot and adapt their strategies in response to market changes and competitive pressures. This dynamic approach ensures that the organization remains relevant and can seize new opportunities as they arise.
- Leveraging Data for Strategic Decisions: In basketball, decisions on whether to focus on rebounds or shooting percentages are often informed by data and analytics. Similarly, business leaders should use data analytics to gain insights into their operations and market trends. This data-driven approach can help identify strengths to capitalize on and weaknesses to address, ensuring that decisions are grounded in reality rather than intuition.
- Emphasizing Team Collaboration and Synergy: Finally, the success of any sports team is as much about individual talent as it is about collaboration and synergy among the team members. In the business context, leaders need to ensure that the organizational structure supports seamless collaboration and communication. Encouraging cross-departmental teamwork can lead to innovative solutions and ideas, much like how a well-coordinated basketball team operates on the court.
For business leaders, the implications are clear: embrace a philosophy of resilience, adaptability, and continuous learning. By viewing failures as stepping stones to success and focusing on strategic strengths, leaders can navigate their companies through uncertainties with confidence. Adopting these lessons from sports can transform challenges into opportunities, propelling the organization toward sustained success and competitive advantage. Also take a look at Carlos Sainz’s approach, whose contract was not renewed by Ferrari to make room for Lewis Hamilton, who will replace Carlos in 2025.
Bottom Line
In conclusion, whether on the basketball court or in the boardroom, the key to sustained competitive advantage lies in a clear-eyed assessment of where one excels and where one may falter. Building strategies around this analysis not only maximizes potential gains but also ensures a robust defense against inevitable challenges, paving the way for enduring success. This strategic approach, rooted in self-awareness, is crucial for any team or organization aiming to not just survive but thrive in their respective arenas.
As the business world moves increasingly towards a model that values adaptability and resilience, the stories of the Knicks and innovative companies highlight a pivotal shift. Embracing imperfection, learning from mistakes, and making continual adjustments are becoming key components of success in both sports and business. The art of capitalizing on the opportunities presented by failures, as demonstrated by the Knicks, serves as a powerful blueprint for businesses aiming to thrive in an era of uncertainty.
>> Back to Insights to find more articles.